Heat pump vs. heat storage: Which solution is the better choice?
Share
The trend toward sustainable heating solutions is steadily growing, and more and more households are looking for efficient alternatives to conventional heating. Heat pumps and thermal storage are among the two most popular options. But which solution is truly better? In this article, we compare the two technologies and explain why thermal storage is often the smarter choice—especially if you value ease of use, cost-effectiveness, and environmental friendliness.
What is a heat pump?
Heat pumps extract heat energy from the surrounding environment (air, water, or ground) and transfer it to the home's heating system. However, this process requires considerable energy, as the heat pump operates with a compressor that requires electricity. Furthermore, a heat pump must operate continuously to generate heat, making it dependent on energy sources and less efficient, especially during cold winter months.
Advantages of the heat pump:
- Environmentally friendly as it uses natural heat sources.
- Low operating costs in mild weather.
- No fuel required.
Disadvantages of the heat pump:
- High power consumption , especially at low temperatures.
- High installation costs and complex installation (especially for geothermal systems).
- Dependence on outside temperatures : The colder it is outside, the less efficiently the heat pump works.
Especially in winter, when heating loads increase, the operating costs of heat pumps can rise sharply. High initial costs and the dependence on temperature and electricity prices make heat pumps not the ideal solution for every household. This is one of the main reasons why more and more people are opting for an alternative: heat storage.
What is a heat storage system?
A heat storage system works very simply: It stores the heat generated by solar thermal energy, photovoltaic systems, or other energy sources, and keeps it available for later use. This allows the stored heat to be used when needed—whether for heating the living space or providing hot water.
Heat storage systems are extremely simple and efficient to operate, as they require no additional energy sources or complex installations. They are an excellent way to optimally utilize and store energy once generated.
Advantages of the heat storage:
- Maximum use of renewable energy : Stores excess heat, generated by solar energy for example, for later use.
- Regardless of the weather : Since the heat is stored in advance, the heat storage remains independent of the weather and can be used at any time.
- Low operating costs : The purchase and operating costs are significantly lower than with a heat pump.
- Easy installation and maintenance : Heat storage tanks are easy to install and require little maintenance.
- Long-term cost-effective : Since the heat storage system makes heat generated once usable again and again, energy costs are permanently reduced.
Disadvantages of heat storage:
- Requires an external heat source such as solar thermal or a heater to generate heat.
- Storage tank required : A heat storage tank requires space for installation
-
While heat pumps appear to be an environmentally friendly choice at first glance, it's often overlooked that they only operate effectively in mild weather. At low temperatures, their energy demand increases exponentially, causing operating costs to skyrocket. Thermal storage, on the other hand, is a simple, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly solution that works particularly well in combination with renewable energy sources.
1. Cost control and profitability
Heat storage systems are often cheaper to purchase and install and are easier to integrate into existing heating systems. Because they access heat that has already been generated—for example, through solar energy—they significantly reduce ongoing operating costs. A heat storage system ensures that heat once generated is not lost, but is always available when needed. This is particularly advantageous because no additional energy is consumed to generate new heat.
2. Flexibility and independence
Unlike heat pumps, which become less efficient in extreme cold, the heat storage system operates independently of the outside temperature. This means you always have the desired heat available without having to worry about additional costs at lower temperatures. The stored heat remains available at any time – regardless of whether it's hot or frosty outside.
3. Environmentally friendly use of surplus energy
Thermal storage systems are an excellent complement to other renewable energy sources such as solar thermal and photovoltaic systems. By storing excess heat generated during the day, they can be used at night or during periods of low sunshine. This sustainable use of available energy minimizes the need for external power supplies and significantly reduces the household's ecological footprint.
Why a heat storage tank is the better choice
While a heat pump may be a suitable solution for some households, in many cases, a thermal storage system proves to be the more economical and efficient alternative. It's straightforward, cost-effective, and, especially when combined with solar energy, extremely environmentally friendly. A thermal storage system offers independence from outside temperatures, controllable costs, and high application flexibility—in short, the perfect solution for a sustainable and efficient heating strategy.
If you want to save costs in the long term and be independent of fluctuations in energy consumption, a heat storage system is the perfect solution. We would be happy to advise you on how to optimally integrate a heat storage system into your heating system and support you in the planning and implementation of this practical and sustainable solution. Contact us today and learn how you can make your heat supply simple and efficient!